When, Where and How May You Legally Record a Conversation? (on the phone or in person)
When, Where and How May You Legally Record a Conversation?
(on the phone or in person)
There are many circumstances in which it makes sense to record a
conversation; such as when negotiating a purchase or sale, modifying
a contract, resolving a dispute, talking with a crazy ex or other
contentious person, etc. You may have thought you need their
permission to record the conversation in order for it to be legal or
admissiable evidence, but in many cases, that ;s not so.
One-Party Recording Rules
First, Federal law permits recording telephone calls and
in-person conversations as long as at least one of the parties
consents to it. If you are the person making the recording and
you are in the conversation then obviously you meet this
requirement. See Federall code, 18 U.S.C. 2511(2)(d). This is
referred to as a "one-party consent".
There are 38 states and the District of Columbia that have
adopted the "one-party consent" law and therefore permit you to
record your phone calls and conversations.
The one-party consent states are:
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- Colorado
- Ohio
- District of Columbia
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Michigan (*)
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Nevada (*)
- Rhode Island (*)
- South Carolina (*)
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Virginia
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin (*)
- Vermont
- Washington
- Wyoming
(*) Additional conditions, from state law or court cases may
apply
States in which permission is required from everyone involved
before recording
Eleven states require the consent of every party on a phone call
or conversation; these are:
- California,
- Connecticut,
- Florida,
- Hawaii (in general a one-party state, but requires two-party
consent is required if the recording device is installed in a
private place),
- Illinois (Illinois courts have ruled that "eavesdropping"
only applies to conversations that the party otherwise would not
have been able to hear, thereby effectively making it a
one-party consent state),
- Maryland,
- Massachusetts (only "secret" recordings are banned),
- Montana (requires notification only),
- Nevada,
- New Hampshire,
- Pennsylvania,
- Washington (however, section 3 of the Washington law states
that permission is given if any of the parties announces that
they will be recording the call in a reasonable manner if the
recording contains that announcement).[30]
How to "notify"
If you are in one of the 11 states that requires a notification
prior to recording, how do you do that? The Federal Communications
Commission defines accepted forms of notification for telephone
recording by telephone companies as:
- Prior verbal (oral) or written notification of all parties
to the telephone conversation. (be sure to save evidence of
that!)
- Verbal (oral) notification before the recording is made.
This is the most commonly used type.
- An audible beep tone repeated at regular intervals during
the call. For example, a "beep" once every 2 minutes.
How to record calls on your cell phone
There are a large number of apps for cell phones that will record
calls. Like any other app, you want to see reviews in teh APple App
Store or Google Play STore to get a good app. Here are some
considerations:
- Does the app allow you to forward the recording to your
computer and play it there?
- The format and clarity of the recording is also important.
For example, some formats make unnecessarily large recording
files which can use up your phone's memory;
- Some formats can only be played back on your phone, and not
forwarded to a computer.
We have tested and used "Automatic Call Recorder" on Android
phones using the "WAV" file setting and it met the above
requirements.
How to record a conversation in person
Your smartphone (Apple or Android) has a recording app built-in.
On Android phones, look for "Voice Recorder". On an iPhone,
look for "Voice Memos"
Recording on an iPhone:
- Launch the Voice Memos app It may be on the Home screen or
in the Utilities folder.
- Tap the red record button.
- Tap the stop button when you are done recording. You can
continue with the same recording, you can hit record again.
- Tap Done when finished recording.
- Type a description into the field if you wish to name your
recording.
- Tap Save.